Osteochondral Injury of the Ankle
An osteochondral injury is damage to both the cartilage surface and the bone directly beneath it, and in the ankle it almost always involves the talus. It matters out of proportion to its size for one reason. It is the most common explanation for an ankle that never fully recovered from a sprain, and it is routinely missed, because the radiographs taken at the time of injury look normal.
Steven Struhl, MD is board certified in orthopedic surgery and holds separate board certification in sports medicine and arthroscopic surgery, earned after a fellowship at Penn State University, and he has practiced in New York since 1991. An ankle still painful and swollen six months after a sprain deserves an MRI rather than another course of therapy.
How Osteochondral Lesions of the Talus Happen
- Ankle Sprain or Fracture: the talus impacting the tibia during the injury, shearing or bruising the surface. Most lesions have a traumatic origin.
- Repeated Injury: several sprains producing cumulative damage.
- Osteochondritis Dissecans: a segment of bone and cartilage separating without a clear single injury, more common in adolescents.
- Interrupted Blood Supply: local osteonecrosis affecting the bone beneath the cartilage.
- Unrecognized Instability: an unstable ankle continuing to load the lesion, which is why the two are so often found together.
Symptoms of an Osteochondral Lesion
- Deep Aching Pain: felt inside the joint rather than over a ligament, and worse with weight bearing.
- Persistent Swelling: recurring after activity, months after the original injury.
- Catching or Locking: if a fragment has separated and is moving within the joint.
- A Sense of Giving Way: which frequently coexists with genuine instability.
- Pain Out of Proportion: to an injury that should have healed by now, which is the most useful clue.
- Stiffness: developing as the joint is protected.
Why These Injuries Are Missed
Plain radiographs are normal in a large proportion of osteochondral lesions, particularly early and particularly when the damage is confined to cartilage. A patient with a sprain, a normal radiograph, and continuing symptoms is frequently told the ankle simply needs more time. MRI is the study that finds these, and it should be ordered when symptoms persist beyond the expected recovery of a sprain, roughly six to twelve weeks. CT is added when the bone involvement needs to be defined precisely for surgical planning, since it shows the size and depth of the bony defect better than MRI does.
Non Surgical Treatment
- Protected Weight Bearing: unloading the lesion in a boot for a period of weeks, which allows some lesions to heal.
- Activity Modification: reducing impact while healing is given a chance.
- Physical Therapy: maintaining motion and rebuilding the strength and balance lost since the injury.
- Addressing Instability: since a lesion in an unstable ankle continues to be loaded abnormally.
- Anti Inflammatory Medication: for symptom control.
Smaller lesions in younger patients, and lesions where the cartilage remains attached, respond reasonably well to a period of protection. Lesions that have separated do not heal on their own.
Surgical Treatment for Osteochondral Lesions
Dr. Struhl performs nearly all of these procedures arthroscopically or through small incisions, and the choice depends on the size of the lesion, whether the fragment is stable, and whether previous treatment has failed.
- Debridement and Microfracture: removing unstable cartilage and drilling the bone beneath to recruit a healing response, the standard treatment for smaller lesions and effective in the majority.
- Fragment Fixation: securing a large separated osteochondral fragment back into its bed, preferred where the fragment is suitable, particularly in younger patients.
- Osteochondral Autograft Transfer: transplanting a plug of bone and cartilage, usually from the knee, into the defect.
- Osteochondral Allograft: donor tissue for larger lesions or after failed prior treatment.
- Cartilage Cell Based Techniques: used in selected patients with larger defects.
- Concurrent Ligament Stabilization: performed at the same sitting where the ankle is also unstable, which it frequently is.
Recovery after microfracture involves a period of protected weight bearing, generally six weeks, followed by progressive loading and rehabilitation, with return to sport at four to six months. Grafting procedures take longer.
Schedule an Ankle Consultation in New York City
An ankle that has hurt and swollen for months after a sprain that should have healed is describing something specific, and the imaging that finds it is not the imaging that was taken on the day of the injury. Dr. Struhl evaluates ankle injuries at his Manhattan and Westchester offices. Contact our office to schedule an appointment.
Medically reviewed by Steven Struhl, MD on