Knee Sprain Treatment
A knee sprain means a ligament has been stretched or torn, and that is the whole of what the term tells you. Which ligament, and how badly, are the questions that determine everything else, and they are not answered by the word sprain.
A knee sprain is a description rather than a diagnosis, and identifying which ligament was injured is what determines the recovery. Steven Struhl, MD is board certified in orthopedic surgery and holds separate board certification in sports medicine, completed his sports medicine fellowship at Penn State University, and has served as a medical consultant to the United States Open tennis tournament.
Knee Sprain Grades
- Grade One: the ligament stretched with microscopic damage, painful but stable on examination.
- Grade Two: partial tearing, with some laxity and a longer recovery.
- Grade Three: complete tear, with clear instability on examination.
Grade describes severity. It does not describe which ligament, and treatment depends on both.
Which Ligament Was Sprained
- MCL: inner side, the most commonly injured, and the most likely to heal without surgery.
- ACL: central, with a pop and rapid swelling, and it does not heal on its own.
- LCL: outer side, uncommon in isolation and often part of a larger injury.
- PCL: central and posterior, often understated at the time of injury.
The pattern of the injury usually points at the ligament before any imaging. Rapid swelling within hours suggests bleeding in the joint and points toward the ACL. Pain along the inner joint line after a blow to the outside of the knee points at the MCL. A knee struck from the front while bent points at the PCL.
Knee Sprain Symptoms
- Pain At A Specific Location: the site of tenderness usually identifies the ligament.
- Swelling And Its Timing: rapid swelling suggests a cruciate tear, gradual swelling suggests otherwise.
- A Popping Sensation: heard or felt at the moment of injury, common with ACL tears.
- Instability: the sense the knee will give way, indicating a higher grade injury.
Knee Sprain Recovery Time
- Grade One: typically one to three weeks to return to activity.
- Grade Two: roughly three to six weeks, depending on the ligament involved.
- Grade Three MCL: eight to twelve weeks with bracing, usually without surgery.
- Grade Three ACL: reconstruction is generally required, with return to sport at nine to twelve months.
Those figures diverge so widely because the ligaments differ so much in their capacity to heal. The MCL has good blood supply and heals reliably. The ACL sits within the joint fluid and does not.
When to Be Seen
- Rapid Swelling: significant swelling within a few hours suggests bleeding within the joint.
- Inability To Bear Weight: difficulty walking on the leg after the initial injury.
- A Sense Of Giving Way: the knee buckling during normal activity.
- No Improvement: symptoms not clearly settling over the first one to two weeks.
Schedule a Knee Evaluation in New York City
A knee sprain that is not clearly improving within a couple of weeks is usually telling you the grade was underestimated or the wrong ligament was assumed, and both are settled quickly with a proper examination. Dr. Struhl evaluates knee ligament injuries at his Manhattan and White Plains offices. Contact the practice to schedule an appointment.
Medically reviewed by Steven Struhl, MD on